DIRTFinds

Guthrie's Locksmith Shop

Locksmith · McAllen, TX

Residential
Active

About

Guthrie's Locksmith Shop operates as a family owned business in McAllen since 1950. They handle locksmith work for cars homes and businesses along with selling heavy duty safes and a range of locks including high security models and padlocks. The shop sits at 1200 Pecan Blvd and serves customers across the Rio Grande Valley with services that cover key cutting programming and lock work for both residential and commercial needs.

Customers often show up with stuck ignition keys on Hondas or need new fobs and chipped keys cut for trucks like Silverados and F150s. Some arrive after big box stores and dealerships turned them away on e-bike keys or camper top locks. Jesse took on a discontinued camper handle job that two other dealers quoted at eight hundred dollars and finished a working set of keys in three hours. Grant and Alex cut and programmed car and house keys in under ten minutes for several people while others got tailgate keys matched to existing ignitions at low cost.

The shop keeps regular hours and handles walk ins with quick turnaround on most key jobs. Reviewers note fair pricing compared to dealers and same day results on programming and cutting. Work covers the McAllen area and nearby spots in the valley with staff who explain fixes on the spot when time runs short at closing.

Most reviews praise the speed and accuracy on key work along with helpful staff on complex jobs. A few mention issues with keys that needed extra trips or higher prices on remotes. The business holds a 4.5 rating across listed feedback.

Service Areas

McAllen

DIRT Score Breakdown

Google

361 reviewsView on Google →

4.5

DIRT Score = confidence-weighted rating across verified review platforms. How is this calculated? →

What Customers Say

“Key got stuck in my ignition + clicker fell apart after a listing appointment • Didn’t feel safe turning off my car, so I drove straight here stressed • They were calm, knew exactly what to do, and fixed it fast • Reassured me this happens often (especially with Honda) Made me feel safe and taken care of highly recommend 🙏 thank you”

Mary Ann Garcia

“Guthries is the best place for keys! My keys were made in less than 2 minutes. Had previously gone to Lowes, Home Depot and Walmart with no success.”

Janie Brown

“Great fast, accurate and friendly service. I get all the copies of my keys done here”

Hugo Morales

“They fixed and got me a new key fob and key! I called them one day they had it ready the next! Very reasonable price and great customer service. Don’t go to anyone on social media for your key or the expensive dealerships. Come here, 10 out 10 recommend! Love them!!”

Alexandria Cantu

“Always good on cutting my keys. Great Service”

Fernando Mendoza

“They did locks and keys at my former campus and at my new one. Reliable, reasonable, and fast!”

Hugo De La Rosa III

“Got recommended here by a friend who is a locksmith. First time i went to get 1 key with chip cut for my 2008 silverado, they charged me 5$ and it comes with free programming but the guy who cut it explained to me how to program it cause they were gonna close in 10 minutes on a friday and when i tried it it didnt work, it wouldn't turn the ignition and by then they had already locked the doors. when i took the 2nd weeks later to get cut since i thought the 1st one was over cut i told them to check it and it needed a small cut on the tip. So both keys worked and they charged me 10$ that time for both keys to cut so 15$ total. There is a sign that says there is no guarentee on cut keys. Then last week i called to see if they can cut my 2009 G8 flip key since mine was the blank fixed key and they said they could but it would be 40$ since its lazer cut but they wouldn't program it(which is fine cause on my car you can program the fob on the DIC) . Got it cut and it worked perfect. Prices are fair, i don't call around for prices no more i just go here now.”

Sixto Guerra

“We have a 2018 F150 with an ARE CAMPER TOP. We didn’t have a key to lock up the camper. Two ARE Dealers quoted us almost $800 to replace both handles and lock assembly since they are discontinued. We called several locksmith’s and were told they couldn’t make us a replacement key. We called Guthrie’s in McAllen. We spoke with Jesse and he asked us to bring in our unit and he would try his best to help us out. We removed the lock cylinder and he asked us to allow him to give it a try…. 3 hour later, we had a new set of keys! Exactly customer service! It’s like he took it as a challenge since everyone else turned us away! Thank you Jesse for the excellent customer service! 🙏🏽”

Enrique Pina

“Knowledgeable and the pricing is reasonable. I have been several times while swapping key format on my current project. I highly recommend be it for the homeowner, contractor, or locksmith. They stock mortise, rim, and household locks.”

Thomas Papke

“Went in for keys. They were fast and accurate.”

Rock rodriguez

“The best small business for keys!! Grant and Alex are always very helpful and print my keys in under a minute. They also are extremely helpful with making car/truck keys and programming same day. Way better prices than dealership too. Thanks guys! 100% recommend if you need house keys or replacement car key.”

Andrea Resendez

“Straightforward, Fast, and Exactly What I Needed. Let me keep it plain and simple—this is the spot if you’re tired of big box stores wasting your time and that “new tech nonsense” making basic stuff like copying a key way more complicated than it needs to be. I’ve been hunting around like crazy trying to find someone who could copy my e-bike keys, which are not your average house keys. These look kind of like car keys, and every kiosk (Walmart, HEB, etc.) just assumes it is a car key and then blocks you from copying it. No way around it. And at Home Depot? The associate looked at my key, blinked at the machine, and hit me with the classic, “uhhh maybe not”... Yeah, real helpful. So Guthrie’s was one of my last hopes. I had called ahead and they told me to bring the key in so they could check. I showed up on a hot day, sweaty, not in the mood, not expecting much. Handed them my two e-bike keys and asked if they could copy them. No nonsense. The guy took them, cut two fresh ones—about $5 each—and had them ready in under three minutes. He even let me test them on the spot to make sure they worked. Spoiler alert: they worked perfectly. I’ll be honest—I didn’t walk in all cheerful,”

DayTrip TookItTo10

“Had them make me a key and they did it super quickly I was surprised it was done so fast but left my they new key to long that I gotta pull it out to turn it. Still they tried offering me to program my key for 80$ after they charged me 10.83$ for a key that doesn’t even work. Had to go to the dealer ship to get everything fixed. 100% would not recommend this place.”

Rene Osornio Jr

“Highly recommend this spot for any locksmithing needs. Needed a key made for the ignition on my Honda VTX project bike and this spot has been recommended to me for years, by everyone. Grant helped me out with stellar customer service, and I had my new key in about 10 minutes for an absolutely fair price. There's a reason this is the only recommended place for locksmithing needs and I will certainly be back again next time I need their services.”

brandon mccann

“Had the best experience with key replacement all thanks to alex and grant! Everyone working was extremely helpful and got me an entirely new set of car keys so so fast. 100% will recommend everyone get all your keys done here!”

Yasmin Gonzales

“This is a first class place to come and get keys made!!! I’ve had many keys made here before and never had any problems with them. They also have safes large ones for guns or other things and small ones for important stuff like documents. Also they have all kinds of lock for home doors and pad locks for storage buildings or trailer doors too. I believe they can also come to over home for installation but I suggest you call them first just to verify on that”

Preston Angell

“I needed a key made for my trucks tailgate. The gentleman who tended to my request, was very helpful and efficient. Instead of two keys, he made my ignition key work with the tailgate lock. Which was not the original. Convenient and affordable. I'm one happy and appreciative customer. I highly recommend. Thank you.”

Yoli Osorio

“This place is a mess, the store looks nice from the inside, we came to replace key with remote start which price was nothing CHEAP $308 and they were fast to charge….as soon as we left outside to try to turn it on NOTHING Next thing you know, the employee was looking for a key…..at first the gentlemen were acting all confident and cocky, we were waiting and nobody would acknowledge us or even give and explanation…… CUSTOMER SERVICE SUCKS WE CAME BACK THIS 2nd TIME BECAUSE THE 1st time we came the gentlemen named Robert helped us out fast and knew what he was doing, fortunate he no longer works in this establishment. Don’t waste your time or money here go to Premier Locksmith - Mission”

Damaris Monsivais

“They have the best service I went to get two keys done . They were done very fast with great quality. I was in and out so fast. Keys worked great. I was glad to tip the guy. I highly recommend it the place was spotless, fresh. Very convenient parking. This is hands on my new locksmith. 🤟😎”

The Guy

“Very quick and excellent customer service. Great price too. Recommend to everyone.”

Laura 2831 Salazar
← All Locksmiths in Mcallen

Last updated: