DIRTFinds

Best Locksmiths in Amarillo, TX

Looking for the best locksmith in Amarillo, TX? DIRT Finds ranks 10 locksmiths by DIRT Score — a real aggregate of Google and Yelp ratings. Compare contractors side by side and request free quotes from local professionals.

#1 Rated Locksmith in Amarillo

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo

4.4DIRT Score

370 reviews

View Profile →
10contractors listed

The ranked list is free and ordered by DIRT Score. Sponsored spots sit in a separate block above it.

Last updated:

Best Locksmith in Amarillo — By Category

Best Value

Best Value Locksmith in Amarillo

Pauls Keys and remotes

4.1★150 reviews

Top-ranked for value and fair pricing among Amarillo locksmiths, with a DIRT Score of 4.1 across 150 reviews.

“Definitely recommend Paul's! I had been calling all over town for prices on a new key for my car and was getting quotes between $300-$400. When I called Paul's I was quoted a…”
Fastest Response

Fastest Locksmith in Amarillo

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo

4.4★370 reviews

Top-ranked for response time among Amarillo locksmiths, with a DIRT Score of 4.4 across 370 reviews.

“I was very satisfied with this company. I locked my keys in my car with it running. I called and in less than 45 minutes, they showed up, had my vehicle unlocked, and I was on my…”
Best Quality

Best Quality Locksmith in Amarillo

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo

4.4★370 reviews

Top-ranked for quality of work among Amarillo locksmiths, with a DIRT Score of 4.4 across 370 reviews.

“Bought 2 keys off Amazon. Has them come out and cut/program them both. Took less than 30 minutes and they both work perfectly. Quick and friendly service. 10/10”
Best Communication

Best Locksmith for Communication in Amarillo

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo

4.4★370 reviews

Top-ranked for communication among Amarillo locksmiths, with a DIRT Score of 4.4 across 370 reviews.

“I purchased 2 blank keys from Amazon for my Honda Accord Crosstour and called Slim Jims to cut and program for me. The cost for one key was $110.00 and the 2nd key was an…”
Best for Homes

Best Locksmith for Homes in Amarillo

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo

4.4★370 reviews

Top-ranked for residential work among Amarillo locksmiths, with a DIRT Score of 4.4 across 370 reviews.

“I locked my keys in my car after work. I called Slim Jim and they were at my house within 15 minutes of the phone call. It took him less than 1 minute to get into my car. The…”

Categories are derived from customer reviews across Google, Yelp & Facebook. DIRT Score is a weighted average across all platforms.

Top 10 Best Locksmiths in Amarillo

Ranked by DIRT Score
🥇

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo

370 reviews · +1806-342-4408

4.4/5

DIRT Score

🥈

Pauls Keys and remotes

150 reviews · +1806-437-4365

4.1/5

DIRT Score

🥉

Pop-A-Lock Amarillo

270 reviews · +1806-355-3008

4.0/5

DIRT Score

4

Frog's Safe and Key

98 reviews · +1806-353-5397

3.9/5

DIRT Score

5

Keyhole Lock and Safe

83 reviews · +1806-356-9006

3.9/5

DIRT Score

6

Affordable Keys Plus

76 reviews · +1806-803-2539

3.8/5

DIRT Score

7

KeyMe Locksmiths

7 reviews · +1806-419-4121

3.5/5

DIRT Score

8

Lockout Legends

38 reviews · +1806-808-2450

3.4/5

DIRT Score

9

KeyMe Locksmiths

6 reviews · +1806-414-3670

3.3/5

DIRT Score

10

Minute Key

1 reviews · +1303-565-8490

0.0/5

DIRT Score

DIRT Score = weighted average of Google & Yelp ratings. Updated monthly. Add your business →

10 locksmiths in Amarillo

Locksmiths near Amarillo, TXOpen in Maps →

Frequently Asked Questions

Which locksmith in Amarillo has the best prices?

Pauls Keys and remotes ranks first for value and fair pricing among Amarillo locksmiths. DIRT Score 4.1 across 150 reviews.

Which locksmith in Amarillo responds the fastest?

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo ranks first for response time among Amarillo locksmiths. DIRT Score 4.4 across 370 reviews.

Which Amarillo locksmith does the highest quality work?

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo ranks first for quality of work among Amarillo locksmiths. DIRT Score 4.4 across 370 reviews.

Which locksmith in Amarillo communicates best with customers?

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo ranks first for communication among Amarillo locksmiths. DIRT Score 4.4 across 370 reviews.

Who should I hire for locksmith work on a home in Amarillo?

Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo ranks first for residential work among Amarillo locksmiths. DIRT Score 4.4 across 370 reviews.

Who are the best locksmiths in Amarillo?

Based on DIRT Score (aggregated from Google and Yelp), the top-rated locksmiths in Amarillo are: Slim Jim's Lock & Key Service of Amarillo, Pauls Keys and remotes, Pop-A-Lock Amarillo.

How much does a locksmith cost in Amarillo?

Costs vary by job type and scope. Request free quotes from multiple locksmiths in Amarillo to compare pricing.

Are locksmiths in Amarillo licensed?

Most locksmiths in Amarillo, TX are required to carry a state license. Always confirm before hiring.

How is the DIRT Score calculated?

The DIRT Score is a weighted average of ratings from Google and Yelp, weighted by review count. It gives you a single, honest number to compare contractors at a glance.